HOW CAN WE HELP?

Schedule Free Consultation

    CONTACT US

    Our Locations

    Philadelphia

    1800 JFK Blvd. Suite 1400 Philadelphia, PA 19103

    (215)-666-7777

    Malvern

    101 Lindenwood Dr. Suite 225W Malvern, PA 19355

    (484)-474-9990

    Plymouth Meeting

    600 West Germantown Pike Suite 400W Plymouth Meeting, PA 19462

    (484)-474-9991

    Radnor

    150 N. Radnor Chester Rd. Suite F-200W Radnor, PA 19087

    (610)-557-1620

    Cherry Hill

    5 Perina Blvd Suite 701 Cherry Hill, NJ 08003

    (610)-541-2500

    When Driver-Assist Fails: Can the Car Manufacturer Be Held Liable?

    Posted on | November 19, 2026 |

    New cars come loaded with technology that can brake, steer and keep pace with traffic on its own. These driver-assistance features can prevent crashes, and they are a step toward fully self-driving cars. But they are not perfect, and many drivers trust them more than they should. When a safety system fails and someone is hurt, the vehicle manufacturer may be held responsible.

    The Safety Features on Today’s New Cars

    Most new vehicles now include some combination of these systems, often called advanced driver-assistance systems (ADAS):

    • Automatic emergency braking (AEB): brakes on its own when it senses a likely crash with a vehicle or pedestrian ahead.
    • Forward collision warning: alerts the driver to a possible crash ahead.
    • Lane departure warning and lane keeping assist: warns the driver or steers the car back when it drifts out of its lane.
    • Adaptive cruise control: keeps a set distance from the car ahead, slowing and speeding up with traffic.
    • Blind spot monitoring and rear automatic braking: warns of vehicles in blind spots and can brake when backing up.
    • Hands-on and hands-free highway systems: combine steering and speed control, such as Tesla Autopilot and Full Self-Driving (Supervised), GM Super Cruise and Ford BlueCruise.

    Automatic emergency braking is set to become standard. In 2024, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) adopted a rule requiring it on new passenger cars and light trucks by September 2029, estimating it would save at least 360 lives a year, according to NHTSA. Automakers have challenged the rule, and federal regulators have said they plan to revise parts of it.

    Driver-Assist Is Not Self-Driving

    Even the most advanced systems sold to the public today are driver-assistance systems, not self-driving cars. They require the driver to watch the road and be ready to take over at any moment. Names like “Autopilot” and “Full Self-Driving” can give drivers a very different impression.

    How Drivers Come to Rely on These Systems

    Research shows many drivers overestimate what these features can do. In a 2022 survey of about 600 regular users, the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) found that 53% of Super Cruise users, 42% of Tesla Autopilot users and 12% of Nissan ProPILOT Assist users said they were comfortable treating their vehicles as fully self-driving, FierceSensors reported. IIHS President David Harkey said early adopters “still have a poor understanding of the technology’s limits.”

    That trust is understandable. When a system works smoothly for hundreds of miles, drivers relax, look at their phones or stop scanning the road. When the system then misses a hazard, there may be only seconds to react.

    When the Technology Fails

    Driver-assistance failures can take many forms, including:

    • Failing to detect a stopped vehicle, pedestrian or obstacle
    • Braking suddenly for no reason, sometimes called “phantom braking”
    • Steering out of the lane or failing to follow a curve
    • Not warning the driver in time to take over
    • Struggling in glare, fog, darkness or other poor visibility

    Federal regulators are investigating several systems:

    • Tesla Full Self-Driving: in March 2026, NHTSA upgraded its investigation into crashes in low-visibility conditions, finding the system did not detect conditions that impaired its cameras or warn drivers until just before crashes, Transport Topics reported.
    • Ford BlueCruise: in January 2025, NHTSA expanded its investigation into about 129,000 Mustang Mach-E vehicles after two fatal crashes into stopped vehicles, TechCrunch reported.

    Can the Manufacturer Be Held Liable?

    Yes, in many cases. Under Pennsylvania product liability law, a manufacturer can be responsible when a defect in its product causes injury. Claims involving driver-assistance systems often involve one or more of these theories:

    • Design defect: the system was designed in a way that made it unsafe, such as failing to detect common hazards or failing to keep the driver engaged.
    • Manufacturing defect: a sensor, camera or component was faulty or installed incorrectly.
    • Failure to warn: the manufacturer did not adequately warn drivers about the system’s limits, or its marketing suggested the car could do more than it can.

    In Tincher v. Omega Flex (2014), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court held that a person can prove a product’s design was defective by showing either that the danger was unknowable and unacceptable to an ordinary consumer, or that the risks of the design outweighed the cost of making it safer. Whether a product is defective is generally a question for the jury.

    A Driver’s Mistake Does Not Always Let the Manufacturer Off the Hook

    Manufacturers often argue that the driver was to blame for not paying attention. But a driver’s mistake does not automatically clear the company.

    In 2025, a federal jury in Miami found Tesla 33% responsible for a 2019 crash in Key Largo, Florida, in which a driver using Autopilot reached for a dropped phone and hit a parked SUV, killing a 22-year-old woman and seriously injuring a man. The jury awarded compensatory and punitive damages totaling about $243 million against Tesla. In February 2026, a federal judge rejected Tesla’s request to overturn the verdict, Claims Journal reported, and Tesla was expected to appeal. That case was decided under Florida law, but it shows that juries are willing to hold manufacturers accountable when their technology contributes to a crash.

    Evidence Is Critical, and It Can Disappear

    Modern cars record a great deal of data, including speed, braking, steering inputs, whether driver-assist was engaged and what warnings were given. Some manufacturers also collect camera footage and system logs. This information can show whether the technology failed, but it can be lost if the vehicle is repaired, scrapped or updated.

    If you were hurt in a crash where driver-assistance technology may have played a role, a lawyer can act quickly to preserve the vehicle and its data. Learn more on our vehicle safety system defect lawyer page.

    What to Do After a Crash Involving Driver-Assist Technology

    • Get medical care right away.
    • Call the police and get a copy of the crash report.
    • Write down which driver-assist features were on and anything the car did or failed to do, such as warnings or sudden braking.
    • Take photos of the vehicles, the scene and the dashboard if it shows alerts.
    • Do not let the vehicle be repaired, sold or scrapped until you have spoken with a lawyer.
    • Avoid giving a recorded statement to an insurance company or the manufacturer before getting legal advice.

    Talk to a Philadelphia Vehicle Defect Lawyer

    Wieand Parker Arreola, PLLC, represents people injured by defective vehicles and vehicle technology in Pennsylvania and New Jersey. If you or a loved one was hurt in a crash involving a driver-assistance system, call (215) 666-7777 or contact us online for a free consultation. You can also read about our work on self-driving vehicle accidents and technology and AI injury claims.

    This article provides general information and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

    FDA Adds Vision Loss (NAION) Warning to Ozempic, Mounjaro and Other GLP-1 Drugs
    Previous

    FDA Adds Vision Loss (NAION) Warning to Ozempic, Mounjaro and Other GLP-1 Drugs

    Next

    When AI Causes Harm: Who Can Be Held Liable, and How to Prove It

    When AI Causes Harm: Who Can Be Held Liable, and How to Prove It

    INSIGHTS & BLOGS

    Recent Posts

    FDA Adds Vision Loss (NAION) Warning to Ozempic, Mounjaro and Other GLP-1 Drugs

    FDA Adds Vision Loss (NAION) Warning to Ozempic, Mounjaro and Other GLP-1 Drugs

    When AI Causes Harm: Who Can Be Held Liable, and How to Prove It

    When AI Causes Harm: Who Can Be Held Liable, and How to Prove It

    Waymo Pulls Robotaxis Off U.S. Freeways: What It Means for Philadelphia

    Waymo Pulls Robotaxis Off U.S. Freeways: What It Means for Philadelphia